Negotiating Jewishness through genetic testing in the State of Israel

Noa Sophie Kohler

doi:10.14512/tatup.30.2.36

Authors

Noa Sophie Kohler The Jacques Loeb Centre for the History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev (IL) https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0722-5360 noasophi@post.bgu.ac.il

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14512/tatup.30.2.36

Keywords:

genetic ancestry testing, Jewishness, essentialism, citizenship

Abstract

In Israel, several hundred thousand citizens form a minority group that wishes to be acknowledged as Jewish by the state authorities. Most of them immigrated from the former Soviet Union and cannot provide sufficient evidence of their maternal ancestors’ affiliation with a Jewish community. This has a direct impact on their civil rights. Based on a scientific research article on matrilineal genetic markers among Eastern and Central European Jews, the rabbinical dean of an institute for advanced Jewish studies in Jerusalem proposed to accept, under certain conditions, the presence of specific genetic markers as legal proof of “Jewishness.” Genetic testing here is meant to become a tool for empowerment and (re)claiming Jewish status. This case raises many questions concerning a biological understanding of Judaism and shows how genetic ancestry testing could be used to uphold the religious orthodox narrative.

References

Abu El-Haj, Nadia (2012): The genealogical science. The search for Jewish origins and the politics of epistemology. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.

Amit, Karin (2018): Identity, belonging and intentions to leave of first and 1.5 generation FSU immigrants in Israel. In: Social Indicators Research 139, pp. 1219–1235.

Atzmon, Gil et al. (2010): Abraham’s children in the genome era. Major Jewish diaspora populations comprise distinct genetic clusters with shared Middle Eastern ancestry. In: The American Journal of Human Genetics 86 (6), pp. 850–859.

Azoulay, Moran (2019): Revealed. Rabbinate making Israelis undergo Jewish DNA test before being allowed to marry. In: Ynet News. Available online at https://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-5476939,00.html, last accessed on 28. 01. 2021.

Behar, Doron et al. (2006): The matrilineal ancestry of Ashkenazi Jewry. Portrait of a recent founder event. In: The American Journal of Human Genetics 78 (3), pp. 487–497.

Behar, Doron et al. (2010): The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people. In: Nature 466 (7303), pp. 238–242.

Brodwin, Paul (2002): Genetics, identity, and the anthropology of essentialism. In: Anthropological Quarterly 75 (2), pp. 323–330.

Carmel, Yosef (2014): Determining Jewishness based on DNA testing. In: Yosef Carmel and Moshe Erenreich (eds.): BaMar’eh HaBazak, 9 (2), pp. 94–129. [original in Hebrew]

Carmel, Yosef (2016): Determining Jewish identity on the basis of genetic testing. In: Eretz Hemdah Newsletter, Pesach 5777, p. 2–3. Available online at http://www.eretzhemdah.org/Data/UploadedFiles/SitePages/3276-sFileRedir.pdf, last accessed on 18. 05. 2021.

Costa, Marta et al. (2013): A substantial prehistoric European ancestry amongst Ashkenazi maternal lineages. In: Nature Communications 2013 (4), p. 2543.

Devir, Nathan (2020): Israel’s immigration policies and the promotion of genetic testing. Empiricizing definitional criteria, bolstering state demographic security, or hastening the Messianic Era? Journal of the Middle East and Afrika 11 (1), pp. 65–85.

Edelman, Martin (1994): Courts, politics, and culture in Israel. Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia.

Efron, John (1994): Defenders of the race. Jewish doctors and race science in Fin-de-Siècle Europe. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Egorova, Yulia (2014): Theorizing “Jewish genetics”. DNA, culture, and historical narrative. In: Laurence Roth and Nadia Valman (eds.): The Routledge handbook of contemporary Jewish cultures. London: Routledge, pp. 353–364.

Egorova, Yulia (2018): DNA, reconciliation and social empowerment. In: The British Journal of Sociology 69 (3), pp. 546–551.

Elhaik, Eran (2016): In Search of the Jüdische Typus. A proposed benchmark to test the genetic basis of Jewishness challenges notions of “Jewish Biomarkers”. In: Frontiers in Genetics 7, p. 141.

Falk, Raphael (2015): Genetic markers cannot determine Jewish descent. In: Frontiers in Genetics 5, p. 462.

Gibel Azoulay, Katya (2003): Not an innocent pursuit. The politics of a ‘Jewish’ genetic signature. In: Developing World Bioethics 3 (2), pp. 119–126.

Glenn, Susan (2002): In the Blood? Consent, descent, and the ironies of Jewish identity. In: Jewish Social Studies 8 (2/3), pp. 139–152.

Kirsh, Nurit (2003): Population genetics in Israel in the 1950s. The unconscious internalization of ideology. In: Isis 94 (4), pp. 631–655

Kravel-Tovi, Michal (2012): ‘National mission’. Biopolitics, non-Jewish immigration and Jewish conversion policy in contemporary Israel. In: Ethnic and Racial Studies 35 (4), pp. 737-756.

Kravel-Tovi, Michal (2017): When the state winks. The performance of Jewish conversion in Israel. In: Katherine Pratt Ewing (ed.): Religion, culture, and public life 5. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

Lipphardt, Veronika (2008): Biologie der Juden. Jüdische Wissenschaftler über „Rasse“ und Vererbung 1900–1935. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.

Lipphardt, Veronika (2012): Isolates and crosses in human population genetics. Or, a contextualization of German race science. In: Current Anthropology 53 (S5), pp. S69-S82.

Lustick, Ian (1999): Israel as a non-Arab state. The political implications of mass immigration of non-Jews. In: Middle East Journal 53 (3), pp. 417–433.

Maltz, Judy (2019): Israeli Rabbinate accused of using DNA testing to prove Jewishness. In: Haaretz. Available online at https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-israeli-rabbinate-accused-of-using-dna-testing-to-prove-jewishness-1.6902132, last accessed on 28. 01. 2021.

McGonigle, Ian (2015): ‘Jewish Genetics’ and the ‘nature’ of Israeli citizenship. In: Transversal 13 (2), pp. 90–102.

Der Spiegel (2006): Vier Urmütter haben 3,5 Millionen Nachkommen. Available online at https://www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/mensch/europaeische-juden-vier-urmuetter-haben-3-5-millionen-nachkommen-a-395551.html, last accessed on 20. 04. 2021.

Parfit, Tudor; Egorova, Yulia (2006): Genetics, mass media and identity. A case study of the genetic research on the Lemba. London: Routledge.

Prainsack, Barbara; Hashiloni-Dolev, Yael (2009): Religion and nationhood. Collective identities and the new genetics. In: Paul Atkinson, Peter Glasser and Margaret Lock (eds.): Handbook of Genetics and Society. London: Routledge, pp. 404–421.

Sharon, Jeremy (2019): Chief Rabbinate admits using DNA tests to help determine Jewish status. In: The Jerusalem Post. Available online at https://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/Chief-Rabbinate-admits-using-DNA-tests-for-Jewish-status-determination-582605, last accessed on 28. 01. 2021.

Times of Israel Staff (2013): Teen told she can’t join Birthright without DNA test. In: The Times of Israel. Available online at https://www.timesofisrael.com/teen-told-she-cant-join-birthright-without-dna-test/, last accessed on 28. 01. 2021.

Ungar-Sargon, Batya (2019): Israeli Rabbis are using DNA testing to police civil rights. This shouldn’t shock you. In: Forward. Available online at https://forward.com/opinion/418775/israeli-rabbis-are-using-dna-testing-to-police-civil-rights-this-shouldnt/, last accessed on 28. 01. 2021.

Yakobson, Alexander (2010): Joining the Jewish people. Non-Jewish immigrants from the former USSR, Israeli identity and Jewish peoplehood. In: Israel Law Review 43 (1), pp. 218–239.